주은영(2007-04-27 18:16:01, Hit : 1996, Vote : 287
 알렉산더 아프로디시아스, 아리스토텔레스 '범주론' 주석서 신판본 일부 발견 소식

Stephen Clark wrote:


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/6591221.stm

A bit of commentary, probably by Alexander of Aphrodisias, on Aristotle's Categories, has turned up in the Archimedes palimpsest.


Actually it's more than a bit; there are seven double-sided leaves (each folded in half to make two leaves in the palimpsest). To be sure, the commentary is sufficiently leisurely in style (which is characteristic of Alexander) that what we have is in a sense only a small part of the whole.

The credit for the arguments that suggest it's Alexander's commentary should be given to Marwan Rashed in Paris. In essence, (a) the commentary cites and discusses the views of Herminus, mid-second century AD, so must be later than that; but (b) it mentions *both* interpretations of Plato's Timaeus, as indicating a literal beginning of the world and as not actually doing so, without definitely taking sides between them, which makes it unlikely that it is by a Platonist since the question is one on which Platonists had definite views one way or the other. That leaves as the obvious candidates Alexander and Galen, both of whom wrote commentaries on the Categories now lost, and there seems no reason to suppose that it's Galen.

General informaton on the palimpsest and on this text at www.archimedespalimpsest.org



Best wishes,


Bob Sharples


Prof. R.W. Sharples, Department of Greek and Latin,
University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK.
tel.: 020-7679 4577 (departmental office & answerphone: 020-7679 7522). fax: 020-7679 7475.
e-mail: r.sharples@ucl.ac.uk



김진성 (2007-04-28 12:32:41)
"A provisional translation of the commentary is currently being undertaken.
It reveals a debate on some aspects of Aristotle's theory of classification, such as: if the term "footed" is used for animals, can it be used to classify anything else, such as a bed?
The passage reads:
For as "foot" is ambiguous when applied to an animal and to a bed, so are "with feet" and "without feet". So by "in species" here [Aristotle] is saying "in formula".
For if it ever happens that the same name indicates the differentiae of genera that are different and not subordinate one to the other, they are at any rate not the same in formula." (링크된 기사 일부)

방송사에서 주석서의 내용까지 상세하게 소개하는 걸 보니 대단하네요. 범주론 3장의 유, 종, 종차의 서술관계에 대한 논의(1b 16-20)를 소개해 놓았군요. 부풀리기만 좋아하는 우리의 언론 방송사는 언제 이런 수준까지 될까요. 텍스트 편집의 출간과 그 내용에 대한 논의를 기대해 봅니다. 좋은 정보 감사합니다.
김주일 (2007-04-30 09:46:32)  
신문사 때문에 홍역을 겪고 있는 저희로서는 참으로 부러운 일입니다. 주은영 선생님 오랜만에 소식 반가웠습니다. 연구에 열중하신다는 소식으로도 듣겠습니다.
김진성 (2007-04-30 12:29:03)
김주일 선생님, 학당에 수요일에만 나가 얼굴 한 번 못뵈는 군요. 오랫만에 인사 드립니다.
AurlieSlkt (2022-07-08 02:51:41)
williams interactive slots
casino world slots
free games
ShaynaSlkt (2022-07-14 23:20:27)
dissertation proposal writing help
dissertation proposal help
dissertation database
JoeteSlkt (2022-07-16 11:44:34)
dissertation proposal template
master dissertation
writing dissertations
ChandaSlkt (2022-07-21 02:31:23)
books thesis dissertation help
dissertation search
professional writing service
AvivaSlkt (2022-07-21 20:51:22)
dissertation help methodology
law dissertation writing service
help with my dissertation
DortheaSlkt (2022-07-22 16:22:31)
dissertation writing services reviews
defending your dissertation
proposal and dissertation help 2000 words
VerieeSlkt (2022-07-23 10:09:48)
thesis or dissertation
online dissertation help veroffentlichen
phd dissertation writing service
SuzannSlkt (2022-07-24 11:37:11)
dissertation help galway
undergraduate dissertation
thesis dissertation
SalliSlkt (2022-07-25 06:01:31)
master dissertation
dissertation literature review
dissertation proposal writing services
DarsieSlkt (2022-07-26 02:06:49)
phd dissertation
buy art online berlin
doctoral dissertation defense
TandiSlkt (2022-07-26 02:39:05)
win money online
casino sites
online casinos no deposit
MabelleSlkt (2022-07-26 23:54:03)
buy a dissertation
writing an abstract for a dissertation
uf dissertation award
TandiSlkt (2022-07-27 03:40:59)
us online casino
mobile casino
free spins casino
JenneeSlkt (2022-07-27 21:34:59)
getting help online
proposal and dissertation help 3000 words
bestdissertation
AbagaelSlkt (2022-07-28 04:46:01)
bingo online for money
real money online casinos
free casinos bonus
HerminaSlkt (2022-07-28 18:14:54)
dissertation proofreading services
proposal and dissertation help geography
dissertation express
ShaylaSlkt (2022-07-29 04:19:26)
casino bonus online
real money casinos
blackjack app real money
AudreSlkt (2022-07-29 13:59:48)
marketing acknowledgement
proquest dissertation
dissertation help in delhi
VerenaSlkt (2022-07-30 03:17:45)
best online casino welcome bonus
free online casino no deposit
free sign up bonus online casino
HestiaSlkt (2022-07-30 09:54:21)
writing doctoral dissertation
writing an abstract for a dissertation
cheap dissertation writing
DixieSlkt (2022-07-31 01:47:04)
best usa online casinos
casino bonuses
real money no deposit casino
LaureenSlkt (2022-07-31 23:38:09)
internet casino bonus
free casino bonus
casino no deposit free bonus
FranniSlkt (2022-08-02 00:22:37)
casinos online real money
online casino game real money
more casino games
PearlSlkt (2022-08-02 22:41:37)
free bonus slots
free cash bonus no deposit casino
free money no deposit casino
BobbieSlkt (2022-08-03 21:06:43)
real casino games online
best casino sites
no deposit on line casinos
LeslieSlkt (2022-08-04 19:30:59)
online casinos for real money
best bonus casinos
american online casinos
TrudieSlkt (2022-08-07 19:16:41)
casino sign up bonus no deposit
real cash online casino
online casino reviews usa
HonorSlkt (2022-08-08 03:25:33)
good free vpn
best free mobile vpn
best vpn for windows 2022
JaynellSlkt (2022-08-08 18:32:47)
online casino no deposit
top us online casino
mobile gambeling
TeddieSlkt (2022-08-08 23:38:05)
open source vpn
business vpn
best free vpn?
DulceaSlkt (2022-08-10 02:15:43)
us casino
online casino usa
best deposit casino bonus
CarolanSlkt (2022-08-11 02:31:19)
bingo gamble
casinos online real money
mobile gambeling
JenneeSlkt (2022-08-11 04:26:15)
vpn network
free vpn proxy
best vpn proxy
AshleighSlkt (2022-08-12 00:40:15)
hotspot shield vpn
best completely free vpn
vpn for mac free
FanyaSlkt (2022-08-12 01:55:03)
free bonus no deposit
casino welcome bonus no deposit
no deposit welcome bonus casino
KelseySlkt (2022-08-12 21:26:44)
proton vpn free trial
best netflix vpn
india vpn free
CarolinSlkt (2022-08-13 02:06:34)
casino free money
american online casinos
biggest online casino bonuses
LaurellaSlkt (2022-08-13 19:56:03)
free vpn for computer
best vpn for laptop
using vpn to buy crypto
FifineSlkt (2022-08-14 20:41:57)
best us online casino
online us casinos
free sign up bonus
SheelaghSlkt (2022-08-15 02:55:19)
what does vpn mean
best free vpn for windows 2022
vpn reviews
FifineSlkt (2022-08-15 16:53:13)
bester online casino bonus
online casino free signup bonus no deposit required
top usa online casinos
SheelaghSlkt (2022-08-15 21:53:37)
free vpn for windows 7
the best vpn service
best multi device vpn

Name
Memo      


Password


<크리티아스> 서평입니다. [13]
정암학당 플라톤 전집이 최초?/미디어오늘 [6]

Copyright 1999-2022 Zeroboard / skin by zero